14 Comments
User's avatar
Neilo**'s avatar

The Defence Dept boffins are also a classic fit. They simply can’t seem to jettison the flawed analysis and procurement models for materiel that keep producing failures with multi $Billion losses. Although part of that is probably linked to the revolving door into sinecures in that same industry by making “correct” choices during their govt. careers.

Elizabeth Chandler's avatar

About ten years ago journalist Laura Tingle wrote a superb Quarterly Essay on the subject of Amnesja within government

bureaucracies . The acquired knowledge and expertise of members of the bureaucracy had been progressively lost as these people

moved on or retired . Governance suffered accordingly . Laura was worried about this ten years ago . It appears to be getting

progressively worse at this time .

poetinapaperbag's avatar

Das Kapital is what Das Kapital does

And all the lawyers fall in love:

poetinapaperbag's avatar

Gronks are the evolutionary genotype, bred from aspirational Prols who wanted something less strenuous for their little darlings, even if the price is an involution of their darlings' overall intelligence.

So they send their bright young things to public service exams and the like.

Now we know why ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE is filling the evolutionary gap.

Elizabeth Chandler's avatar

Before Zionist continue reading “Welcome to the Gronkocracy” the person who leapt immediately to mind as I read the first

paragraph was Michele Bullock . She fits the description accurately , as her narrow “awareness of tools” to deal with the economy

demonstrates . So many members of the struggling Publjc could assist her …..

Elizabeth Chandler's avatar

Oh dear ! auto correct was angry with me just now , for some reason 🙄. I meant to write , and assumed I had written the word “I”. They substituted

Zionist for the pronoun .

Dan Bluemore's avatar

Mad autocorrect.

CFV's avatar

"...Someone should understand housing as housing, not primarily as a component of inflation; understand what financing costs actually do to construction; somebody should understand household budgets from something other than an aggregate set of statistics;..."

They bow to the sacrosanct computer models and data feeds developed by the clever people and in their ivory tower they are too far removed from the common man and so have no understanding of their problems or even a touch of empathy.

Niemoller's Ghost's avatar

Liked: 'What institutions need is organised intellectual friction: people with enough knowledge to understand the prevailing argument and enough independence not to be impressed just because everybody important accepts it.'

HappyHouse's avatar

An important solution would be to restore education to what it once was when a questioning, inquisitive, broad thinking, critical mind was rewarded. Now it seems that students are simply being trained to do as they are told and pass exams.

David Lewis: Cultural Notes's avatar

There’s a form of gronkocracy in education. Curricula focused on exam results not learning.

Dan Bluemore's avatar

It's economic dogma isn't it. The only way to deal with inflation is x, no matter the causes.

I'm not necessarily aware of what various other approaches are available, but I did come across something that explained how Nixon's administration dealt with inflation in the 70's with price controls. It seems that specific example was poorly implemented (possibly as it was more about winning an election) but it appears there is a way better example from ww2.

And I guess this is partly the point of this article, that they refuse to consider other means to fix the problem.

However, I'm not 100% that they just don't want to open their minds. I think it's more because the current thinking and policies ensures the economy works for those at the top, not the majority of us.

Dean Kiley's avatar

I'll be thinking about, and arguing with others about, this incisive widely-instrumental framework and persuasive analysis, for a long time.

And, of course, wedging 'gronkocracy' into conversation A LOT.

Joe Gargery's avatar

Seems there's a kind of gronkism at play in this article. Monetary policy's role isn't to, despite the reserve bankers' pious hand wringing, serve the whole economy but to make sure capital always wins out against labor. The whole point of interest rate rises is to kick workers in the teeth. Those besuited big brains aren't put upon independent and fair minded arbiters but big businesses' goons.